The mad doctor: The extraordinary story of Dr Rufus May, the former psychiatric patient




Last updated 11/06/2007



Published: Independent, 18 March 2007

At the age of 18, Rufus May was diagnosed as an incurable schizophrenic and locked up in a psychiatric hospital. Now, he is a respected psychologist and a passionate campaigner on mental health issues. He is also the guest editor of this special issue. Here, he tells his extraordinary tale

When I was aged 18, I witnessed first hand how society's approach to mental health wasn't working. I was admitted to Hackney hospital - a psychiatric hospital - and told that I could not leave. On the verge of adulthood, and feeling lost after my girlfriend had left me, I had invested in a spiritual search for guidance. The messages I picked up from the Bible convinced me I had a mission. Seeking to discover what my mission was, I slowly deduced that I was quite possibly an apprentice spy for the British secret service. I was eventually admitted to hospital when I became convinced that I had a gadget in my chest that was being used to control my actions.

Psychiatric hospital was like another world entirely. Queues for the medication trolley punctuated the boredom and general sense of hopelessness. Any resistance to the regime was quashed by forcible restraints and powerful injections. Many friends felt too scared to visit me.

That experience coupled with being given a diagnosis of schizophrenia made me feel like a social outcast. When my parents were told my condition was probably genetically inherited, the die seemed irrevocably cast. Ward rounds felt like elaborate religious rituals conducted by the consultant psychiatrist, with an audience of medical students and student nurses observing, while my insanity was confirmed and long-term drug treatment prophesied. I found the medication made me feel empty and soulless; I could not think past considering my basic needs. The drugs made me physically weaker and affected my hormones so I became impotent.

I was concerned about this. However, to the outside world, because of the mind-numbing effects of the drugs, I was less focussed on my spy and spiritual beliefs. The doctors pronounced that I was responding well to the medication. I was determined to stop taking the tablets and injections as soon as I could find other ways of staying calm and centred.

The majority of fellow patients were revolving-door patients. I myself was told I'd be back. It was true: I was readmitted twice before I managed to escape the role of mentally ill regular customer. But I was luckier than most: as well as my parents visiting me daily, a close friend came back from selling pots and pans to US servicemen in Germany and began visiting me daily too. I started to pick up on her belief that this breakdown, or whatever it was I was having, was something I could get over.

When I was 12 years old, I had witnessed my mother make a strong recovery from a disabling brain haemorrhage, so instinctively I knew that I could turn my life around with the right support. So I decided not to believe in the doctor's wisdom and planned to get a job as soon as I left hospital. While I was still in hospital, I started going to churches and community centres offering to do voluntary work. Although I must have seemed a bit odd, I found many kind people who were willing to give me tasks to do and slowly I started to rebuild some social skills.

When a friend and fellow patient, Celine, took her own life after being heavily over-medicated, it became a turning point for me. It was a Caribbean funeral and hundreds of people turned up for it. It contrasted strongly with the absence of support she had had when she had been alive and hearing abusive voices from her past.

I realised then that I had found a cause that needed no delusions to support it. Like Celine, I had gone through the strange process of being talked to as if I was not there, of professionals trying to suppress my odd and disturbing behaviour with drugs without trying to understand why I was acting as I was. No one seemed willing to think what was it like to walk in my shoes.

We, as a society, were making people madder and maybe I could do something about changing that. What if I could make a different kind of come-back to the psychiatric ward, as a mental health professional? Then perhaps, in Trojan horse style, I could help dismantle the myths of the psychiatric hierarchy. The more I thought about this, the more I realised I would have to keep my former identity as a psychiatric patient strictly under-cover.

When a junior psychologist informally questioned my diagnosis of schizophrenia, suggesting I had had a temporary psychotic episode instead, it made me think maybe psychology was a way of doing things differently. So my mission was becoming clearer: I would train as a psychologist. I knew I needed to sort myself out to some extent before attempting this journey.

My first job, straight out of psychiatric hospital, was working as a night security guard in north London's Highgate Cemetery. I now think that patrolling the heavily wooded grounds in the dark was a deeply therapeutic activity. With no time to daydream, I had to stay aware and face my fears of the dark and the unknown. I also think just walking in close proximity to nature was a very healing process.

It was during this time that I successfully came off my psychiatric medication, against doctors' advice. I then spent several years doing a range of jobs and learning creative ways to express myself, using dance and drama. I shifted my focus from thinking about myself to trying to help others, while making sure I looked after my mind and body. I used the outdoor gym on Parliament Hill, sport and breathing exercises as natural ways to manage my moods. I was careful to avoid unreliable or abusive friends and stick with people who had stuck by me. Studying sociology helped me understand the wider structures of society, demystifying such things as the class system and power relations between men and women.

I was reminded of the prejudice against the subject of mental illness when a right-on community centre refused to support me and a group of amateur drama students putting on a play about a nervous breakdown. Nevertheless, from drama classes I learnt the art of re-inventing oneself through improvisation. I will always remember how one of my drama teachers impressed upon us all the message that "this life is not a rehearsal". My confidence in acting was to become useful over the next 10 years of carework and psychology training, where I chose to keep quiet about my previous role as a psychiatric patient, to avoid the possibility of discrimination.

For me, the dividing line between the mentally ill and the sane was more a question of social boundaries than actuality. I had found some very mad people in hospital very helpful and some of the so-called "well" nurses quite bullying and hostile, it suggested to me that to some extent madness was in eyes of the beholder. I also knew that my own madness had been meaningful; for example, my fantasies about being a spy had given my life meaning and my search for a spying mission was a metaphoric search for a meaningful quest in my life.

My training as a psychologist in the early 1990s, coincided with a time when psychology as a profession was beginning to interest itself in trying to understand and work with madness, an area which was usually associated with the more medical, drug-prescribing profession of psychiatry. For the past 10 years I have been working as a psychologist covering a broad range of mental-health problems. I know that to really help someone who is deeply suffering or confused, we need to be very creative and offer a wide range of resources.

In Bradford we have self-help groups where people are encouraged to help others as well as themselves. We also create spaces where for example art, spirituality and physical relaxation can be explored in a number of different ways. We have Tai Chi classes, dance classes and African art classes, as well as political and cultural discussion groups. If people hear troubling voices, I want to understand these beings that haunt them. I will sometimes communicate directly with the voices and try to facilitate a peace process between the voices and the person hearing them.

I must be living proof that people can resist so-called command hallucinations, because initially many voices feel threatened by me and tell the voice hearer to attack me. I am still unscathed, which is a strong testimony to the fact that people who hear voices can learn to resist the most bullying and aggressive of them. So instead of encouraging people to suppress their experiences, which I think generally makes them worse, I try to assist people to face their demons in their own time.

Is society any madder than 20 years ago when I was in hospital? It seems to me that some things are getting worse and some things are getting better. People are getting bolder in talking about their experiences of distress and madness. This is refreshing; the status quo, in which well-meaning professionals and charity heads are the only experts, is starting to be challenged. Britain is a leading light in this consciousness raising, where people are coming out more and more about their experiences of emotional distress. Consequently, a broader range of ideas and approaches to what helps us heal troubled minds is being listened to.

At the same time, the might of the pharmaceutical industry is stronger than ever before; drug companies are ruthlessly promoting the simplistic and misleading "chemical imbalance" theory of mental distress, while marketing our discontent as diagnosable medical illnesses. In the US, they have been very successful, with roughly 10 per cent of women taking anti-depressants and an astonishing 10 per cent of children being treated for ADHD with the amphetamine derivative Ritalin. Each year in this country, prescription rates rise for psychiatric medication.

While I am not against all use of mind-altering drugs, this trend is worrying. I think that when drugs appear to work, the main effect is that of masking a patient's problems, but as soon as you remove them the problems bounce back, often with a little more oomph due to the fact they have been artificially suppressed. You also need more and more of the drug to achieve the same effect, because our brains build up a resistance to all mood-altering substances. We are then likely to experience the more negative effects of the medication and develop a dependence.

So drugs are limited in their usefulness and are perhaps best used as a last resort and for short periods of time. This is not going to be popular in the board rooms of Big Pharma, the Big Brother of mental health. But if we are going to make progress in our quest for healthier communities, we are going to have to limit the pharmaceutical industry's influence on how we understand our minds and approach the recovery process.





Comments

Leave a response

  1. steve willinghamJune 20, 2007 @ 11:47 PM
    i was kept in a mental hospital in my twenties, i didn't like it at all. in fact i found it a pretty scary place. i have been receiving medication sinse that time and i am now 56! due to medication i have had excrutiating and embarrasing experiences which i was helpless to do anything about. taking depixol for most of my life { i'm now on prozac and amisulpride which have made me somewhat impotent } i constantly struggled all that time against the " zombielike " affect it gives. the side affects were a living nightmare and often were mistaken as mental illness by my friends and loved ones and sometimes even my doctors!!! it seems, from my experience, that the medication, instead of helping a person, creates more problems for them! in fact i have one friend who is receiving such a high dose of injection treatment, he,s incapable of looking after himself and very often feels suicidal about this FACT!!! most of what dr rufus says about the way mental illness is dealt with today, i have also experienced, and he has expressed things which i think are exactly true,but couldn't put into words and there are many many people i am sure, who feel the same way. i was always conscious of the fear of speaking out because like rufus says i would not have been taken seriously, and would probably have been medicated for my efforts. this is a real threat! i always tolerated medication rather than accepted it, and i think most people i know who suffer confusion and mental distress feel the same way.they would like to come off it. i believe mental illness is NOT inherent, but caused by other cruel people and circumstances. in fact that is my EXPERIENCE!!! and, the whole attitude towards people who are treated as mentally ill needs a complete re think! instead of seeing people as a schitzophrenic or a depressive they should first be seen as human beings NOT diseases. i agree entirely that medication is the proverbial " quick fix " and does NOT cure the problem. the question WHY is the key. if we can see WHY or WHAT has caused the problem in the first place we will know exactly what we are dealing with and treat it appropriately!!! this is where psychology comes into the picture; getting to the root of the problem and resolving it so it won't appear again! and peoples opinions about those they know as mentally ill are almost primitive, and definitely discriminatory!!! can u imagine going for a job and telling your prospective employer you have mental illness? my direct expierence, again is, YOU DON'T GET THE JOB!!! how can that help anyone?! this sort of attitude COMPOUNDS the issue rather than helps it!!! we need to take a long hard look at ourselves first, before judging others in a way that will most seriously affect their lives. this discriminatory behaviour, i am sure, has cost the lives of too many people already!!! thankyou for allowing me to have a voice about a very important subject that affects me and many others in so many ways! it is really refreshing to hear the truth about a still taboo subject and to know some people are aware enough to KNOW what to do about a most important issue in todays " modern " world! yours appreciatively, steve willingham
  2. PaulJune 26, 2007 @ 05:41 PM

    Dear Steve

    Thank you for your kind comments about the site and our aims. We would very much agree with you about the problems raised by high dosages and long term use of medication and the issues of stigma and discrimination that you raised in your comments. This is why INTERVOICE sees the issue facing people who voices as being about human rights and choice, rather than as fixing something that is supposedly broken.

    Did you see the recent news article we put up on the site about medication?: "People with schizophrenia not taking antipsychotics more likely to recover, states research." If you´d like to see it go to http://www.psychminded.co.uk/news/news2007/June07/people002.htm

    Best wishes

    Paul
    INTERVOICE

  3. SpamBotJanuary 09, 2008 @ 11:25 AM
    inspiring article, and steve's post was so well said it's hard to follow. i have read some of your other online material and referenced some of it in my recent masters' dissertation. I am also a former patient, diagnosed with a psychotic illness, but fortunately knew enough to challenge my diagnosis and treatment, get off the meds and go back to college. I have however recently had the experience of being forced to stop working as a volunteer at a charity for brain injured patients because they found out i was on disability. All i had told them was that i was attacked 8 years ago and subsequently spent time in hospital after a breakdown. I have just completed an MSc in Cognitive Neuropsychology, and know that their attitude contravened anti discrimination laws but what can i do? They placed impossible conditions on my continued volunteering, knowing that i had just finished full-time education and am a single parent with no recent work experience, demanding 'someone who has worked with you recently and for at least a year who can vouch for your suitablility to work with brain injured patients'. I had already provided good recent academic references, and work references from the past, but they hassled people about this issue unfairly. Other volunteers there tend to be very young or inexperienced students who also have no experience and therefore need the work. This was to play dominoes and bingo with old men! Fortunately I had already experienced the keeness of the local psych hospital to employ me despite having detailed knowledge of my diagnosis, although i feel that i don't want to work in psychiary. Oh, and why did they find out about the disability? I had just got another part-time job and needed to adjust my hours for permitted work (15 hrs per week). That's well-paid, skilled IT work, btw, and my employers there have NO problem with being told the same information..... *sigh*
  4. PeterAugust 13, 2008 @ 08:27 PM
    I was diagnosed with schitzophrenia 3 months ago and somhow got the GP to put down 'stress' on the sick note. I don't think its going to make much difference anyway, my days are numbered. In some ways I can't wait till its all over.
  5. Free ThinkerSeptember 14, 2008 @ 12:46 AM
    I discovered this site recently and wish to express my thanks for the work you do here regarding the phenomenon of voices and mental health. This essay by Dr. May was particularly interesting and I was heartened to see an M.D. speak out against the overuse and misuse of medication in the mental health field. It's truly frightening to think that a Big Brother policy has come to dictate that wild, beautiful, and mysterious place known as the human soul. This shift from accepting life's difficulties as processes by which we grow and become better humans to the brain chemistry/medical model doesn't bode well for our growth, our ability to empathize with others, and to think in a flexible way. People who seek help are put on drugs which make their lives more difficult and frequently result in discrimination, as steve's post above points out. Being mentally ill is seen as their fault, a result of faulty genes. This is a cruel way to look at being human. Medication was pushed heavily during my college years. And just as I would say no to a dealer pushing cocaine, I said no repeatedly to anti-depressants, perferring to work out my problems through independent thinking and at times, through acceptance. I didn't want my happiness and ability to problem-solve be dependent on a corporation to which I'd have to pay a lot of money for their drug. And yes, I've had problems, and yes, it's difficult, but at least when I make a change, it comes from a place of genuine reflection. I saw too many of my friends doped up on drug cocktails, rendering them zombies shuffling through classes, not all there. And I have seen those also become bipolar because of Paxil withdrawal and watched their lives come close to being destroyed. Once you are diagnosed and drugged, you can't go back. I have listened to these friends express their fears about job searching and looking for dates because they are terrified that the "truth" will come out and they will be rejected. It's a sad, frustrating way to go through life. And the arts and humanities have suffered from the cheapening of the soul. Novels used to be big, messy explorations of the soul and our imperfections; now they're manufactured items filled with crass, shallow characters to make money. The classiscs are still taught but I wonder if in another ten years people will no longer be able to understand or relate to what our forebears went through, and how they were able to create and sustain beauty and nobility even in the worst of times. Will we remember how to do this, or will we be so caught up in the medical-biological mode that we will medicate children at the first sign of individuality? Vonnegut's short story "Harrison Bergeron" comes to mind. Music was once glorious, exuberant, and passionate meant to chase the blues away and to get people dancing. Now our ears are deafened by formulaic pop music that serves the purpose of making money. Those who seek to communicate a deeper meaning through honest music have a difficult time finding representation (although YouTube is helping out with that). Medication can be a valuable short-term solution. But it will never be a substitute for honest self-examination and free, independent thinking. In order to grow, we need to experience discomfort, and yes, even pain. If you're depressed or anxious, if you feel psychological pain, it's a profound signal that your life is out of step with your deepest, most life-giving values and priorities. Cast aside the cheapness of media culture and spend time with yourself searching for those values and priorities. It's a difficult, but worthwhile journey. Then, step by step, re-build your life around your values. In time, you will feel better about yourself. You may not be "happy" (at least in the shallow American sense) but you will in time, feel a sense of satisfaction and even a sense of wonder at the mystery of being a human being in this fragile world. Don't let those who seek power and money push you around and convince you there is no higher purpose in life. Peace to all who read this site and are on their personal journeys to recovery and well-being.
  6. HeatherSeptember 23, 2008 @ 02:13 AM
    Just loved this story. So much triumph in it. And Steve's comment was very revealing. But "Freethinker"'s comment should be published! Such profound wisdom. I, too, am incredibly concerned over the use of drugs! I'm an American and our drug companies are supposedly regulated by the Food and Drug Administration or FDA. A recent article in the popular Reader's Digest magazine in the U.S. had an extensive article about how messed up and disorganized the FDA is AND that 50% of its money comes from pharmecutical companies!!! They are basically being bought off!! And the Dr.'s are too as they are given bribes to push drugs - trips to the Bahamas, etc. It's a horrible thing that is happening. An entire generation being destroyed by drugs!
Comment

...have your say here, if you wish to discuss your experiences with other voice hearers and concerned people why not join our discussion forum by completing the joining form

here